1. Health

Discuss in my forum

Is Foot Analysis a Useful Procedure?

Podiatrist Views of Pedorthic Foot Analysis

By , About.com Guide

Updated May 27, 2010

About.com Health's Disease and Condition content is reviewed by our Medical Review Board

See More About:
The foot analysis performed at Foot Solutions stores and by scanning devises such as Dr. Scholls Footmapping kiosks is becoming more widespread. Is this a useful and valid analysis? We asked Dr. Robert Eckles, Dean, Graduate Medical and Clinical Education and Associate Professor, Department of Orthopedic Sciences at the New York College of Podiatric Medicine. He is a member of the New York State Podiatric Medical Association.

"The use of devices such as these is not new. Podiatrists and others have utilized pressure sensing systems for treatment of patients and for research for many. many years. The critical issue, I believe, is in the interpretation of the information generated. As one can get a blood pressure reading in a pharmacy, the information provided by these systems may be clinically useful, or not, depending on who reviews it and is not in itself, diagnostic. The systems cannot specify 'why' such data is observed."

"As a tool for determining where pressure points exist on the foot, the devices clearly signal where these sites exist. But let’s be clear, only a licensed practitioner can take the next step (pardon), to determine why this is the case and whether or not the issue is medically significant."

"In addition, the specific technologies mentioned do not all provide similar information. For example, the AMFIT system is capable of rendering a 3-D image or model of the foot. The other systems you note cannot. This means that decisions may be made based on 2-D imaging supplemented with a 'treatment algorithm' which is, I feel, synonymous with the word approximation. Where these devices are used to produce a product such as a foot orthosis, only a 3-D image of the foot is acceptable, and this can only be obtained through impression casting, 3-D laser scanning, or by using the peg system that AMFIT employs. Production of such a device using pressure sensing technology is at best an approximation."

What A Podiatrist Can Do

"As podiatrists, we are trained (and here, train our students) to think beyond what is outwardly visible, so that a professional interpretation of findings can be done, and this involves gait examination and evaluation of the entire lower limb mechanics and morphology. This is the only way in which a diagnosis (and this is what the foot–sore public needs) can be obtained."

Better Than Nothing?

"I am not opposed to facilities using technology to better fit shoes; in an era of 'find and fit yourself', it is good to see attention paid to the topic. The limitations to such use is that data is just data unless it’s understood and utilized by individuals who are trained to make diagnoses." More: When to Call a Podiatrist

©2012 About.com. All rights reserved.

A part of The New York Times Company.

We comply with the HONcode standard
for trustworthy health
information: verify here.